Which Coffee Maker Makes the Hottest Coffee?

Choosing the right coffee maker requires you to compare a variety of features. One feature that most shoppers tend to overlook is the brew temperature.

You need hot water to make coffee. Water extracts flavor from the coffee grounds. But it needs to reach a specific temperature for best results.

The Specialty Coffee Association of America (SCCA) says water should reach a temperature of 195 to 205° Fahrenheit. This is for optimal coffee brewing.

If the water is too cool, you get weak, sour-tasting coffee. If the water is too hot, the coffee may taste bitter.

So, which coffee maker makes the hottest coffee? It turns out, quite a few. There’s several coffee makers that have brewing temperatures within the recommended range.

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Let’s take a closer look at these five hottest coffee makers for brewing the perfect cup of coffee. It’s brew time!

Disclosure: Some of these links are affiliate links, and at no additional cost, I earn a commission if you buy which helps to maintain this website.

5 Coffee Makers That Make The Hottest Coffee

Redline MK1 Coffee Brewer

The Redline MK1 appears on almost every list of hottest coffee makers. The brew temperature range matches the SCAA recommendation (195 to 205° F). It’s also a versatile machine.

Features:

Drip Rate:

The MK1 includes a lever for adjusting the drip rate and soak times. You can adjust the drip rate to achieve the best results with different coffee grounds.

Slowing the drip rate helps with extraction for a fuller flavor. Increasing the drip rate helps prevent bitter coffee.

Pre-infusion:

The coffee maker is also equipped with a pre-infusion mode. The pre-infusion mode soaks the grounds, allowing them to expand.

As with slowing the drip rate, the pre-infusion mode brings out more flavor.

Design:

The MK1 also stands out for its unique design.

The water reservoir sits to the side of the carafe and uses a separate heating element from the hot plate. This allows the water to reach optimal temperatures quickly.

With the Redline MK1, you can brew a full pot of coffee in just six minutes.

The design is entirely mechanical. This eliminates the risk of electronic components shorting out. It’s also durable and should hold up to daily use.

Size:

The Redline MK1 is a little large. The base measures 13.7 x 7.8 inches, making it deeper compared to most coffee makers.

It takes up more counter space, but only includes an eight-cup carafe. If you drink a lot of coffee, you may prefer a larger coffee maker.

Pros

  • Brews a full pot in six minutes
  • Includes a mechanical lever for adjusting the drip rate
  • The mechanical design is built to last

Cons

  • Takes up more counter space compared to other choices
  • Includes an eight-cup carafe
See on Amazon

OXO Brew 8 Coffee Maker

The OXO Brew 8 Cup Coffee Maker has a brewing temperature of 198 to 205° Fahrenheit. This makes it the highest temperature coffee maker available.

Features:

BetterBrew Technology:

OXO uses original BetterBrew technology. This optimizes water temperature, water volume, and brew time.

The inside of the OXO coffee maker has a microprocessor. This controls the brew cycle to replicate the “pour over” brewing method.

The end result is even extraction and rich flavors when brewing.

Stainless Steel Carafe:

As with the Redline MK1, the OXO coffee maker includes an eight-cup carafe. Yet, instead of glass, the carafe is made from stainless steel.

A stainless-steel carafe is shatter-proof and helps keep the coffee hot.

The base and top of the coffee maker are also made from stainless steel. While the water reservoir is clear polypropylene.

Design:

An eight-cup carafe is small, as many coffee makers include 10-cup or 12-cup pots. But, the OXO coffee maker has a space-saving design.

It’s about 6.75 inches wide and 10.5 inches deep.

It’s a durable coffee maker with a simple design. The only settings include the brew size and a cleaning mode.

Brew Settings:

You can move a lever on the basket to switch between brewing a carafe and brewing a single cup.

When brewing a single cup, you can also remove the carafe and brew straight into your coffee mug.

The OXO Brew 8-Cup Coffee Maker is also one of the more expensive options. But, you get what you pay for.

With this model, that’s the advanced brewing technology and stainless-steel parts.

Pros

  • Brews coffee at a hotter temperature compared to most coffee makers
  • Includes a durable stainless-steel carafe
  • Allows you to brew a single serving or a full pot

Cons

  • One of the more expensive choices
See on Amazon

Ninja CP307 Hot and Cold Brewed System

The Ninja CP307 is packed with features for brewing coffee or tea in a variety of sizes and styles.

It has a brew temperature range of 195 to 205° Fahrenheit, with an average temperature of 200° Fahrenheit.

Features:

Brewing Styles:

The machine includes separate baskets for coffee and tea. It automatically recognizes which basket you insert to display the right brew options.

You can select from six brew sizes, ranging from a single cup serving to a full carafe.

Other options include brewing directly into a cup or into the coffee carafe. The available brew styles include classic, rich, over ice, cold brew, and a specialty brew mode.

Specialty Mode & Menu:

Use the specialty mode for everything from cappuccinos to macchiatos. The coffee maker will adjust the temperature and drip rate based on the setting selected.

The menu is on the right side of the machine and includes a digital clock. The coffee maker is programmable, allowing you to wake up to a fresh pot of coffee.

Carafe & Accessories:

As with the OXO coffee maker, the Ninja CP307 comes with a stainless-steel carafe. It has a 10-cup capacity and can keep your coffee hot for hours.

You also get a couple of accessories. This includes a fold-away frothing tool and a permanent coffee filter.

Instead of using paper filters, you can rinse out the coffee grounds and reuse the filter.

The frothing tool allows you to convert hot or cold milk into a rich foam.

Pros

  • Includes a variety of brew settings, including cold brewing
  • Comes with a stainless-steel carafe
  • Include six brew sizes, including single cup

Cons

  • Takes up more counter space
  • Not the least expensive coffee maker
See on Amazon

Cuisinart DCC 3200 PERFECTEMP Coffee Maker

The Cuisinart DCC 3200 is a 14-cup drip coffee maker. It has a brewing temperature between 198 and 202° Fahrenheit.

Features:

Temperature:

It doesn’t get quite as hot as the previous options. Yet, the temperature is still within the ideal range.

Cuisinart uses advanced tech so that the coffee is brewed at the right temperature.

The hot plate also has an adjustable temperature. You can control this using a button below the display.

Carafe & Size:

The Cuisinart DCC 3200 has a 14-cup glass carafe. This is quite a bit larger compared to the earlier recommendations.

Even with a larger carafe, the Cuisinart coffeemaker takes up minimal space. It measures just 7.755 x 9 x 14 inches.

Settings & LCD Display:

The sleek design includes a backlit LCD with a clock and programmable timer.

You can select from several operating modes. This includes self-cleaning and one to four cup brewing.

The coffee maker also has a button for controlling the brew strength. Select “bold” for stronger coffee and “regular” for a standard pot of coffee.

Reusable Coffee Filter:

The Cuisinart DCC 3200 also comes with a gold-tone permanent coffee filter. You don’t need to buy any paper filters.

The Cuisinart coffee maker is another durable choice. It includes a stainless-steel exterior. Yet, it’s also a little expensive when not on sale.

If cost is a factor, the same coffee maker is available with a plastic matte black exterior at a lower cost.

Pros

  • Comes with a large 14-cup carafe
  • Includes a programmable timer and self-cleaning mode
  • Allows you to brew smaller pots (one to four cups)
  • The sleek design takes up minimal space

Cons

  • Doesn’t get as hot as some of the other coffee makers
See on Amazon

Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Coffee Maker

If your budget is tight, the Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Coffee Maker is an affordable choice. It’s one of the least expensive coffee makers that meets SCAA’s recommendations.

The brewing temperature is between 196 and 205 degrees Fahrenheit.

Features:

Settings:

The Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Coffee Maker is a basic coffee maker with no extra settings.

It features an on/off switch and a water level indicator on the side of the water reservoir. This is to prevent overfilling.

Size:

The coffee maker measures 11.76 x 8.43 inches and stands 12.56 inches tall. It comes with a 12-cup glass carafe.

When you pull the carafe from the coffee maker, it automatically stops brewing. This means you can grab a cup before it’s done brewing.

(Unfortunately I couldn’t find a video with the exact Mr. Coffee Model here. The model in this video is not the same as the model I’m suggesting. You can still get an idea of how it works.)

Hot Plate:

The hot plate has an automatic shut-off feature. It turns off after two hours of use, so you don’t have to worry about turning off the coffee maker.

The Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Coffee Maker is easy to use and affordable. But it doesn’t include any special features or custom settings.

Pros

  • One of the most affordable coffee maker
  • Comes with a 12-cup carafe
  • Easy to use design

Cons

  • Doesn’t include any brew settings
  • It may not last long as some of the other options
See on Amazon

How to Choose the Best Coffee Maker with Hot Brew Temperatures

The brew temperature is just one of several details to consider when buying a coffee maker. You should also pay attention to:

  • Carafe size and material
  • Coffee maker dimensions
  • Brew settings
  • Durability
  • Cost

Carafe Size & Material

The carafe is the coffee pot that comes with the coffee maker. Most carafes have a capacity of 8 to 14 cups.

If you drink a lot of coffee, you may want at least a 12-cup coffee maker. A 12-cup coffee maker can brew about 96 ounces of coffee.

While most carafes are made from glass, some coffee makers have stainless-steel carafes.

Stainless steel carafes don’t shatter when dropped. But they need more frequent cleaning to prevent scale build-up.

Coffee Maker Dimensions

Before purchasing a coffee maker, you should be aware of how much space you’re working with.

It might sound like an obvious thing to do, but I’m sure we’re all guilty of getting excited about a new purchase!

Doing this now will save you lots of time and effort later. Especially if you realise you don’t have the space available that you need.

Who wants to go through the effort of returning goods? Not me!

Grab whatever measuring device you have – a tape measure or even ruler will do.

Measure the available space on your kitchen bench first. Then check on Amazon to see the dimensions of your preferred coffee maker.

Brew Settings

Coffee makers also come with various settings and features.

The most basic coffee makers, such as the Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Coffee Maker, include an on/off switch.

Coffee makers with fewer settings are easier to operate. You can pour water, add coffee grounds, and flip a switch.

If you prefer more control over the brewing process, get a coffee maker with more features.

You can find machines with programmable timers, clocks, temperature settings, and operating modes.

Durability & Cost

The durability and cost of the coffee maker are often connected.

Less expensive coffee makers are more likely to break down within two or three years of daily use.

More expensive coffee makers are typically less prone to wear and tear.

Why Do You Need a Hot Coffee Maker?

Most drip coffee makers include a metal tube below the hot plate.

When you turn on the coffee maker, water passes from the reservoir and through the heated metal tube.

The thin tube limits the flow of water, allowing it to heat quickly.

The hot water rises through a plastic tube and drips over the grounds.

As the basket fills, the hot water soaks the grounds and extracts the flavor to produce coffee.

The SCAA recommends a brewing temperature between 195 and 205° Fahrenheit.

The boiling point of water is 212° Fahrenheit. But, using boiling water ruins the flavor.

Too much heat makes the coffee stronger and more bitter.

Some of the cheaper coffee makers only reach temperatures of 175 to 185° Fahrenheit.

The lower temperatures help keep you from making bitter-tasting coffee. But you also end up with a weaker brew.

Which Coffee Maker Makes the Hottest Coffee? – Conclusion

Using the hottest coffee makers ensures proper extraction. This allows you to unlock the full flavor of the coffee grounds.

Each of the five coffee makers discussed brew within the SCAA recommendation of 195 to 205° Fahrenheit.

The Mr. Coffee Coffee Maker is a great choice for those that just want a simple drip coffee maker.

It’s an affordable machine but may not last more than a few years with regular use.

The remaining options are more durable.

The Redline MK1 offers the best value due to its simple design and reasonable price. But it lacks some of the features found on other options.

For those who want more control over the brewing process, get the Ninja CP307. It includes six brew sizes and five brew styles.

Yet it’s also an expensive coffee maker.

The Cuisinart DCC-3200 is bit cheaper and comes with a large 14-cup carafe.

It includes several settings, including an adjustable temperature for the hot plate.

The OXO Brew 8-Cup Coffee Maker stands out for its durability and ease of use.

You can also switch between brewing a full carafe and a single serve.

No matter which option you choose, you’re sure to get a hot pot of coffee!

Have you tried one of these coffee makers? How did you find it to use?

Have you got another suggestion for what coffee maker makes the hottest coffee?

Let me know in the comments below. Stay Caffeinated!